If This Is Diversity, No Thank You

I’ve gotta agree with Ezra on this one. I have no idea why Janet Napolitano is being considered for a seat on the Supreme Court. She’s not young, she doesn’t have a great legal mind and she’s not particularly liberal.  On top of all that, she doesn’t provide the same opprotunities to “double dip” in the diversity category nor does she have a distinguished legal career. By all of the established liberal criteria, she’s the worst of all the candidates currently being mentioned.

Like I’ve said, I still need to do deeper research into each of the short list candidates, but I’m very dishearted from what I’ve read thus far. This isn’t to say that if nominated any of these candidates would be a bad Supreme Court Justice, but you can’t help but feel that Obama is blowing a huge opprotunity. (Think of it as taking a walk with the bases loaded when you could’ve hit  a grand slam.)

Promoting diversity on the court is a very important goal. But its only part of the puzzle. A young and vibrant court justice with a great legal mind would do much more to advance the rights of women and minorities, even if its a white male. But…and this is a VERY important but, Obama’s inability to select a great group of candidates should not be considered an argument against promoting diversity on the court. There are plenty of women and minorities candidates that would be home runs. It just appears that they’re not on Obama’s list.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “If This Is Diversity, No Thank You

  1. I know this is going to sound lazy, since I could probably just wikipedia this, but has there ever been a Native American on the Supreme Court? I’m not trying to barge in on the minority thing but when this whole thing came up I started wondering if there have every been a non-white/black/hispanic judge would do to the Supreme Court. I assume there haven’t been any Asian justices either?

  2. “A young and vibrant court justice with a great legal mind would do much more to advance the rights of women and minorities, even if its a white male.”

    Couldn’t agree more but some people just want the mental satisfaction of having “their” candidate representing them in positions of power. I think some people aren’t so much opposed to having diversity on the bench or in congress but they would rather it be the other guy’s candidate who is replaced. Unfortunately for white people it’s probably usually a white person who is replaced, which is a hit to their ego, but a necessary one. We’ve got a long ways until everyone is the same color (metaphorically and literally).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s